Uncommon Descent

Archive for the 'Uncategorized' Category

1 March 2010

A malodorous argument for Darwinian evolution

Michael J. Behe

University of California evolutionary biologist John Avise has penned a book, Inside the Human Genome: A Case for Non-Intelligent Design, and gotten it published by a top academic publishing house, Oxford University Press. Avise, a member of the National Academy of Sciences, has for decades been a leading researcher in evolutionary and ecological genetics. He [...]

15 February 2010

Misusing Protistan Examples to Propagate Myths about Intelligent Design

Michael J. Behe

The Journal of Eukaryotic Microbiology recently published several papers from a workshop sponsored by the International Society of Protistologists entitled “Horizontal Gene Transfer and Phylogenetic Evolution Debunk Intelligent Design.” So here we have a respected scientific society, presumably planning a workshop months in advance, and finally laying out their considered case for why intelligent design [...]

29 October 2009

Response to Carl Zimmer and Joseph Thornton, Part 4

Michael J. Behe

The science writer Carl Zimmer posted an invited reply http://tinyurl.com/yhpm3t7 on his blog from Joseph Thornton of the University of Oregon to my recent comments about Thornton’s work. This is the last of four posts addressing it. References appear at the bottom of this post.
At the end of his post Thornton waxes wroth.
Behe’s argument has [...]

28 October 2009

Response to Carl Zimmer and Joseph Thornton, Part 3

Michael J. Behe

The science writer Carl Zimmer posted an invited reply http://tinyurl.com/yhpm3t7 on his blog from Joseph Thornton of the University of Oregon to my recent comments about Thornton’s work. This is the third of several posts addressing it. References will appear in the last post.
Now back to Thornton’s first point, the role of neutral mutations (which [...]

27 October 2009

Response to Carl Zimmer and Joseph Thornton, Part 2

Michael J. Behe

The science writer Carl Zimmer posted an invited reply http://tinyurl.com/yhpm3t7 on his blog from Joseph Thornton of the University of Oregon to my recent comments about Thornton’s work. This is the second of several posts addressing it. References will appear in the last post.
Now to Professor Thornton’s reply. He writes at length but makes just [...]

26 October 2009

Response to Carl Zimmer and Joseph Thornton, Part 1

Michael J. Behe

The science writer Carl Zimmer posted an invited reply http://tinyurl.com/yhpm3t7 on his blog from Joseph Thornton of the University of Oregon to my recent comments about Thornton’s work. This is the first of several posts addressing it. References will appear in the last post.
I must say, it never ceases to amaze me how otherwise-very-smart folks [...]

21 October 2009

New work by Richard Lenski

Michael J. Behe

A new paper from Richard Lenski’s group has appeared in Nature http://tinyurl.com/ygtcflq and has garnered a fair amount of press attention (for example, here http://tinyurl.com/yh7nqht ). Some people asked me for my thoughts about it.
The new paper continues the grand experiment that Lenski has been publishing about lo these many years [...]

12 October 2009

Nature publishes paper on the edge of evolution, Part 3

Michael J. Behe

Nature has recently published an interesting paper which places severe limits on Darwinian evolution. The manuscript, from the laboratory of Joseph Thornton at the University of Oregon, is entitled “An epistatic ratchet constrains the direction of glucocorticoid receptor evolution”. ( http://tinyurl.com/yeq2cy8 ) The work is interpreted by its authors within a standard Darwinian framework, but [...]

5 October 2009

Nature publishes paper on the edge of evolution, Part 2

Michael J. Behe

Nature has recently published an interesting paper which places severe limits on Darwinian evolution. The manuscript, from the laboratory of Joseph Thornton at the University of Oregon, is entitled “An epistatic ratchet constrains the direction of glucocorticoid receptor evolution”. ( http://tinyurl.com/yeq2cy8 ) The work is interpreted by its authors within a standard Darwinian framework, but [...]

30 September 2009

Nature publishes paper on the edge of evolution, Part 1

Michael J. Behe

Nature has published an interesting paper recently which places severe limits on Darwinian evolution. This is the first of several posts discussing it.
The manuscript, from the laboratory of Joseph Thornton at the University of Oregon, is entitled “An epistatic ratchet constrains the direction of glucocorticoid receptor evolution”. ( http://tinyurl.com/yeq2cy8 ) The work is interpreted by [...]